Recording

   Discuss technical issues with the community. Mixvibes staff provides no support on this board.
Forum rules
Click here to join MIxvibes on DISCORD https://discord.gg/gMdQJ2cJqa

Recording

Postby Marxon on 22 Nov 2012, 12:39

May someone could explain me something:
I know if a mp3 file is played while the signal gets
recorded via audio out/in and later the recorded file also gets encoded to mp3 then there will be again a data loose caused by compression.
How is this handled from software playback and recording like recording in Cross?
Does it happen there too?
Does it matter if record in mp3 or wave format?

Thanks for the info!
Best regards
Marxon
Image
MEMBER OF:

:cool: People MV Society :cool:

FLAC Tag minority

---------------------------------------
Cross 3.0 / Producer 7.5 / Cross Remote App
Korg Zero 8, Kaoss Pad 3
Alesis AirFX
Roland SP303
Novation Remote SL 49 MK2
iPad 4
---------------
Midibox SEQUENCER V4
http://midibox.org/forums/gallery/album/164-marxon%C2%B4s-seq-v4/
Midibox SID V2 Synth
User avatar
Marxon
 
Posts: 787
Joined: 02 Nov 2007, 14:30
Location: Germany / Plauen (Vogtl.)


Re: Recording

Postby christiankoopmann on 22 Nov 2012, 12:58

Hey,

when you record from software output (like recording directly the master out (when dual stereo for example) you will have a smaler less of quality than recording the route back from the mixer to your computer.
it is depending on your soundcard and the mixer and so on how the quality will be.

Generall when you are playing MP3 I would prefere you to record also in MP3 (take care that you will have the same quality setted ;)). Wave is only bigger and will not bring back the sound which you would have if you running original wave files ;).

So record in good quality with MP3 and it will be enough (most people have not the ears and also the equipment to get a better sound). To get the full wave sound you need a realy good soundcard and also speakers which can play those frequences :D.

regards
Christian
Image
Image
February 2012 Mixvibes DJ of the Month
DVS 7, Cross (DJ), U-Mix Remote App (iPad & iPhone App)

MEMBER OF:
:cool: c00l People MV Society :cool:
User avatar
christiankoopmann
 
Posts: 1823
Joined: 19 Dec 2008, 16:44
Location: Paderborn, Germany


Re: Recording

Postby Hannes on 22 Nov 2012, 16:18

christiankoopmann wrote:Hey,

when you record from software output (like recording directly the master out (when dual stereo for example) you will have a smaler less of quality than recording the route back from the mixer to your computer.
it is depending on your soundcard and the mixer and so on how the quality will be.

Generall when you are playing MP3 I would prefere you to record also in MP3 (take care that you will have the same quality setted ;)). Wave is only bigger and will not bring back the sound which you would have if you running original wave files ;).

So record in good quality with MP3 and it will be enough (most people have not the ears and also the equipment to get a better sound). To get the full wave sound you need a realy good soundcard and also speakers which can play those frequences :D.

regards
Christian


Disagreed!

Since the Audio is converted to .wav in the software I´d recommend you to record in .wav as well, it may be bigger but

1) you dont have the data-conversion going on while playing (cpu-load)
2) you still can convert it to mp3/m4.a or whatever afterwards

Another point:
Depending on your Gear, you might have a "better" sounding file when recording from your mixer.
(If you have a mixer which´s sound you really like)

Of course Chris is right when saying, the quality is better when recording internally
(like CD is better audio-quality than Vinyl, Vinyl still sounds better ;) )
June 2012 Mixvibes DJ of the month

https://soundcloud.com/han-nes-10/fridaybeatdown2ndedition
no support by pm

beta troll

Macbook Pro 13, late 2011, 6GB RAM, 480GB Crucial M500
Thudrumble TR-1S, Vestax VFX-1, ESI Maya USB+, Rane SL2
User avatar
Hannes
 
Posts: 4168
Joined: 07 Dec 2010, 02:57
Location: Vienna


Re: Recording

Postby christiankoopmann on 22 Nov 2012, 17:00

Hey,

to the CPU load, I have an P3 3Ghz HT Computer and there I can run Cross and my record software no.23 and everything is working without any problems so on a good optimised system you can record on what you want ;).

regards
Christian
Image
Image
February 2012 Mixvibes DJ of the Month
DVS 7, Cross (DJ), U-Mix Remote App (iPad & iPhone App)

MEMBER OF:
:cool: c00l People MV Society :cool:
User avatar
christiankoopmann
 
Posts: 1823
Joined: 19 Dec 2008, 16:44
Location: Paderborn, Germany


Re: Recording

Postby Support@MixVibes on 23 Nov 2012, 12:38

I prefer to record in WAV, because I will always give some processing/post prod to the file before putting it back to MP3.
User avatar
Support@MixVibes
 


Re: Recording

Postby Hannes on 23 Nov 2012, 13:29

Support@MixVibes wrote:I prefer to record in WAV, because I will always give some processing/post prod to the file before putting it back to MP3.


Audacity ftw!

Audiobots: Normalize!
:lol:
June 2012 Mixvibes DJ of the month

https://soundcloud.com/han-nes-10/fridaybeatdown2ndedition
no support by pm

beta troll

Macbook Pro 13, late 2011, 6GB RAM, 480GB Crucial M500
Thudrumble TR-1S, Vestax VFX-1, ESI Maya USB+, Rane SL2
User avatar
Hannes
 
Posts: 4168
Joined: 07 Dec 2010, 02:57
Location: Vienna


Re: Recording

Postby Marxon on 24 Nov 2012, 13:20

Ok thanks for your informations guys!
Now i think we need working FLAC tags in Cross even more.

Marxon
Image
MEMBER OF:

:cool: People MV Society :cool:

FLAC Tag minority

---------------------------------------
Cross 3.0 / Producer 7.5 / Cross Remote App
Korg Zero 8, Kaoss Pad 3
Alesis AirFX
Roland SP303
Novation Remote SL 49 MK2
iPad 4
---------------
Midibox SEQUENCER V4
http://midibox.org/forums/gallery/album/164-marxon%C2%B4s-seq-v4/
Midibox SID V2 Synth
User avatar
Marxon
 
Posts: 787
Joined: 02 Nov 2007, 14:30
Location: Germany / Plauen (Vogtl.)



Return to Community Support




Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 85 guests

Board index

 
 
   
 
© 2014 Mixvibes