RoJeC wrote:Hi Ian,
Seems you don't have had your credentials automatically set right when registering your license key. Please send a PM to Unclevibes to have this sorted (or the mv support contact).
Don't think the forum structure will change soon by adding a more branched structure, as over time the number of branches only have been reduced. Latest revision of the forum was appx. a year ago.
Biggest problem seems to be that users describe the same problem by using different terminology. That's why the search function doesn't always give a good answer at once. Also quite some issues seem to have more or less the same keywords.
IMHO revising the forum will be a tremendous job, without solving to much of the mentioned issues.
And more general regarding MIDI. This isn't that easy to support further than buttons that "talk". As LEDs don't talk and there is no standard on naming LEDs (nor associated color options), let alone conditional combinations it is just a dream to have this in a monkey proof general tool. You do need the MIDI values of a controller to be able to manipulate it.
Thanks for the reply RoJec. You provided a lot of good information about how MV handles MIDI maps. I had no idea that there was no industry standard for LED feedback, but this is precisely my point. Most people don't know this! Unlike you RoJec, the forums don't make this clear. So what ends up happening to new users is the same thing as the bloke from Manchester (my experience was the same, and still is to an extent). It's only because the software and the community is so strong that I stuck with it. I would really like to hear your suggestions RoJec (please PM me if you cannot continue this here).
Bottom line is that MV competition makes finding MIDI map information easier.
So forget the wiki or revamping the forum. You seem to believe there are some issues here that could be improved. What controllers would you like to see RoJec? I've made some other suggestions to improve the user experience with MV MIDI mapping, are any of these changes on the table?
-More COMPLETE maps (not just transport and jog wheel. IMO if MV doesn't have the time or resources to make *complete* mappings then maybe they should only map the tricky stuff like LED feedback, and leave the easier stuff like transport, for the user).
-More COMPLETE maps for *mid/high-end* controllers
-Scripting language for mappings would be *HUGE*
-Compatible controller list needs a refresh/update
And to keep this on topic, please consider mapping:
Gemini MDJ 1000
In general, MixVibes staff is doing and incredible job. Your hard work has made me a big supporter of the software, and I'm excited about it's future. Keep up the great work MixVibes!
-BFT